Connect with us

News

US Supreme Court appears split over controversial use of ‘geofence’ search warrants

info

Published

on

Geofence keyword warrants.jpg

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday heard arguments in a landmark legal case that could redefine digital privacy rights for people across the United States.

The case, Chatrie v. United States, centers on the government’s controversial use of so-called “geofence” search warrants. Law enforcement and federal agents use these warrants to compel tech companies, like Google, to turn over information about which of its billions of users were in a certain place and time based on their phone’s location.

By casting a wide net over a tech company’s stores of users’ location data, investigators can reverse-engineer who was at the scene of a crime, effectively allowing police to identify criminal suspects akin to finding a needle in a digital haystack.

But civil liberties advocates have long argued that geofence warrants are inherently overbroad and unconstitutional as they return information about people who are nearby yet have no connection to an alleged incident. In several cases over recent years, geofence warrants have ensnared innocent people who were coincidentally nearby and whose personal information was demanded anyway, been incorrectly filed to collect data far outside of their intended scope, and used to identify individuals who attended protests or other legal assembly.

The use of geofence warrants has seen a surge in popularity among law enforcement circles over the last decade, with a New York Times investigation finding the practice first used by federal agents in 2016. Each year since 2018, federal agencies and police departments around the U.S. have filed thousands of geofence warrants, representing a significant proportion of legal demands received by tech companies like Google, which store vast banks of location data collected from user searches, maps, and Android devices.

Chatrie is the first major Fourth Amendment case that the U.S. top court has considered this decade. The decision could decide whether geofence warrants are legal. Much of the case rests on whether people in the U.S. have a “reasonable expectation” of privacy over information collected by tech giants, like location data.

It’s not yet clear how the nine justices of the Supreme Court will vote — a decision is expected later this year — or whether the court would outright order the stop to the controversial practice. But arguments heard before the court on Monday give some insight into how the justices might rule on the case. 

‘Search first and develop suspicions later’

The case focuses on Okello Chatrie, a Virginia man convicted of a 2019 bank robbery. Police at the time saw a suspect on the bank’s security footage speaking on a cellphone. Investigators then served a “geofence” search warrant to Google, demanding that the company provide information about all of the phones that were located a short radius of the bank and within an hour of the robbery. 

In practice, law enforcement are able to draw a shape on a map around a crime scene or another place of significance, and demand to sift through large amounts of location data from Google’s databases to pinpoint anyone who was there at a given point in time.

In response to the geofence warrant, Google provided reams of anonymized location data belonging to its account holders who were located in the area at the time of the robbery, then investigators asked for more information about some of the accounts who were near to the bank for several hours prior to the job. 

Police then received the names and associated information of three account holders — one of which they identified as Chatrie.

Chatrie eventually pleaded guilty and received a sentence of more than 11 years in prison. But as his case progressed through the courts, his legal team argued that the evidence obtained through the geofence warrant, which allegedly linked him to the crime scene, shouldn’t have been used.

A key point in Chatrie’s case invokes an argument that privacy advocates have often used to justify the unconstitutionality of geofence warrants.

The geofence warrant “allowed the government to search first and develop suspicions later,” they argue, adding that it goes against the long-standing principles of the Fourth Amendment that puts guardrails in place to protect against unreasonable searches and seizures, including of people’s data.

As the Supreme Court-watching site SCOTUSblog points out, one of the lower courts agreed that the geofence warrant had not established the prerequisite “probable cause” linking Chatrie to the bank robbery justifying the geofence warrant to begin with. 

The argument posed that the warrant was too general by not describing the specific account that contained the data investigators were after.

But the court allowed the evidence to be used in the case against Chatrie anyway because it determined law enforcement acted in good faith in obtaining the warrant.

According to a blog post by civil liberties attorney Jennifer Stisa Granick, an amicus brief filed by a coalition of security researchers and technologists presented the court with the “most interesting and important” argument to help guide its eventual decision. The brief argues that this geofence warrant in Chatrie’s case was unconstitutional because it ordered Google to actively rifle through the data stored in the individual accounts of hundreds of millions of Google users for the information that police were looking for, a practice incompatible with the Fourth Amendment.

The government, however, has largely contended that Chatrie “affirmatively opted to allow Google to collect, store, and use” his location data and that the warrant “simply directed Google to locate and turn over the necessary information.” The U.S. solicitor general, D. John Sauer, arguing for the government prior to Monday’s hearing, said that Chatrie’s “arguments seem to imply that no geofence warrant, of any sort, could ever be executed.”

Following a split-court on appeal. Chatrie’s lawyers asked the U.S. top court to take up the case to decide whether geofence warrants are constitutional.

Justices appear mixed after hearing arguments

While the case is unlikely to affect Chatrie’s sentence, the Supreme Court’s ruling could have broader implications for Americans’ privacy.

Following live-streamed oral arguments between Chatrie’s lawyers and the U.S. government in Washington on Monday, the court’s nine justices appeared largely split on whether to outright ban the use of geofence warrants, though the justices may find a way to narrow how the warrants are used.

Orin Kerr, a law professor at the University of California, Berkeley, whose expertise includes Fourth Amendment law, said in a lengthy social media post that the court was “likely to reject” Chatrie’s arguments about the lawfulness of the warrant, and would likely allow law enforcement to continue using geofence warrants, so long as they are limited in scope.

Cathy Gellis, a lawyer who writes at Techdirt, said in a post that it appeared the court “likes geofence warrants but there may be hesitance to fully get rid of them.” Gellis’ analysis anticipated “baby steps, not big rules” in the court’s final decision.

Although the case focuses much on a search of Google’s location databases, the implications reach far beyond Google but for any company that collects and stores location data. Google eventually moved to store its users’ location data on their devices rather than on its servers where law enforcement could request it. The company stopped responding to geofence warrant requests last year as a result, according to The New York Times.

The same can’t be said for other tech companies that store their customers’ location data on their servers, and within arm’s reach of law enforcement. Microsoft, Yahoo, Uber, Snap, and others have been served geofence warrants in the past.

When you purchase through links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. This doesn’t affect our editorial independence.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Champions Stunned: Abia Warriors Crush Lagos Knights 35–12 as Samuel Gbemisola Steals the Show in Showtime Flag Football League Season XV

info

Published

on

Lagos Womens Team on the Field 1024x577.png

Abia Warriors delivered one of the standout performances of Showtime Flag Football League Season XV on Sunday, dismantling defending champions Lagos Knights 35–12 in a commanding display at Showtime Arena, Lagos.

READ ALSO: Agbayewa’s Hat-Trick Seals Thriller: Cross River Ikan Sports Edge Delta Braves 34–31 in Showtime Flag Football League Season XV | Sports247 Nigeria

The two-time Showtime Bowl champions were ruthless from the opening exchanges, racing into a remarkable 29–6 halftime lead and leaving the Knights struggling to recover.

Samuel Gbemisola was named the official Match MVP after an outstanding performance that produced two receiving touchdowns, 57 receiving yards, a perfect 10.0 rating and 7.2 fantasy points.

Abia Warriors wasted little time announcing their intentions. Quarterback Joseph Williams opened the scoring with a 34-yard touchdown pass to Jumai A.O, before the Warriors’ defence created another opportunity.

An interception by Ipense Oloruntoba against Lagos quarterback Kayode Mafe handed Abia possession, and Williams capitalised by finding Gbemisola for a two-yard touchdown.

With Abia leading 15–0, Williams continued to torment the Knights’ defence, connecting with Mistura Subair for a four-yard touchdown before delivering another four-yard scoring pass to Success Patrick.

That fourth touchdown stretched the advantage to an astonishing 29–0, putting the defending champions under enormous pressure.

Lagos Knights eventually responded when Mafe found Dimieari Dabo-Green for a 20-yard touchdown, reducing the deficit to 29–6 before halftime.

However, any hopes of a second-half comeback were quickly dented.

Abia Warriors resumed their attacking dominance, with Bello Anuoluwapo finding Gbemisola for another two-yard touchdown to extend the lead to 35–6.

The Knights continued searching for a response, but Abia’s defence remained disciplined. Oloruntoba added another interception against Mafe, completing an impressive defensive contribution.

Lagos managed a late consolation when Mafe connected with Anyaorah Lotanna for a 35-yard touchdown, but it was nowhere near enough to threaten the Warriors’ advantage.

The match ended 35–12, giving Abia Warriors a statement victory over the reigning champions.

Williams topped the fantasy standings with 10.4 points, ahead of MVP Gbemisola on 7.2, while Lagos Knights receiver Lotanna finished third with 5.1.

For Abia Warriors, the result was more than just another victory. It was a reminder of the quality that previously carried them to Showtime Bowl XII and XIII titles.

For Lagos Knights, the defeat exposed vulnerabilities that will demand attention as the battle for honours in Season XV intensifies.

Final Score: Abia Warriors 35–12 Lagos Knights

Match MVP: Samuel Gbemisola (Abia Warriors) — 2 receiving touchdowns, 57 receiving yards, 10.0 rating, 7.2 fantasy points.

Top Fantasy Performers:

1. Joseph Williams (Abia Warriors, QB) — 10.4 FP
2. Samuel Gbemisola (Abia Warriors, Receiver) — 7.2 FP
3. Anyaorah Lotanna (Lagos Knights, Receiver) — 5.1 FP

THE GAME IS THE SHOW!

Continue Reading

Business

NNPC Wins Global Branding Award for Petroleum Retail Excellence

info

Published

on

The Nigerian National Petroleum Company (NNPC) Limited, has won the 21st World Branding Forum (WBF) Award in the petroleum retail sector category for its impact in driving innovation in Nigeria and in setting excellence benchmark in the nation’s petroleum retail sector.

The prestigious award was conferred on the Company during the WBF’s 2026-2027 Awards ceremony held at Hampton Court Palace, London, recently.

Speaking at the occasion, Chairman of World Branding Forum (WBF), Richard Bowles said: “We celebrate NNPC Limited for earning public trust, delivering exceptional experiences and consistently pushing the NNPC brand and setting benchmark for excellence in petroleum retail sector in Nigeria and across its borders”,

Bowles further explained that NNPC Limited was selected after a rigorous evaluation process which encompasses brand valuation, consumer market research and public online voting.

“You have earned it and people should know, tell your customers, tell your staff, put it on your website and in your marketing campaigns”, Rowles stated.

Responding shortly after receiving the award, Managing Director of NNPC Retail Ltd, Huub Stokman thanked the WBF for the recognition, stressing that it will spur the company to do more towards providing the best value and experience for its teeming customers.

Stokman, who was represented by the Director, Operations of the NNPC Retail Ltd., Baba Kukawa, dedicated the award to the entire staff of the Company, adding that the Company is deploying cutting-edge technology to upscale and expand its operations.

Also present at the event were the Manager, External Communications and Brand Management, NNPC Ltd., Mr. Mohammed S. Umar and Manager, Marketing, NNPC Retail Ltd., Mrs. Henrietta A. Ogon.

The World Branding Awards (WBA) is an international brand‑recognition program run by the World Branding Forum, a London‑based non‑profit organisation.

Incorporated in 2014, the WBA has operated for over a decade, honouring global, regional, and national brands through a three‑stream judging process: brand valuation, public voting, and market research. The awards recognise outstanding achievement in brand building, consumer trust, and market influence across industries worldwide.

Some of its past recipients include recognised energy brands such as Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (ADNOC) Distribution and PTT Stations.

The post NNPC Wins Global Branding Award for Petroleum Retail Excellence appeared first on Business Today NG.

Continue Reading

Trending