Speculation over a possible defection by Plateau State Governor, Barrister Caleb Mutfwang, to the All Progressives Congress (APC) has intensified following the circulation of newly branded APC shirts and caps online, heightening political tension across the state.

The rumours emerge at a time when the APC in Plateau is undergoing rapid consolidation under its newly elected National Chairman, Professor Nentawe Yilwatda Goshwe. Since assuming office, Professor Nentawe has been credited with restoring internal discipline, unity, and strategic focus—drawing major political stakeholders back to the party.

Within six months, the Plateau APC has recorded several high-profile defections, including former allies of Governor Mutfwang, political bloc leaders, and grassroots mobilisers. Political analysts say the surge reflects widespread confidence in Nentawe’s inclusive leadership and growing dissatisfaction with what defectors describe as the PDP’s “internal crisis.”

However, rumours that Governor Mutfwang may be considering a move to the APC have triggered strong resistance within the party. Some party loyalists argue that unlike governors from other states who defect with strong political structures, Mutfwang lacks meaningful influence. They note that all but one National Assembly member from Plateau, as well as 22 of the 24 members of the State House of Assembly, are already in the APC. Several of the governor’s close associates—including his campaign Director General and ward chairman—have also crossed over.

The strongest pushback has come from the Association of Decampees to the APC, led by Hon. Mutbel Danlami. Speaking at a press briefing on 11 November 2025, the group dismissed the speculation and cautioned both the state and national leadership of the APC against admitting the governor.

Describing the Mutfwang administration as “hostile, exclusive, and directionless,” the group accused the governor of tribal favoritism, selective governance, and neglecting loyal supporters. Hon. Mutbel likened the idea of admitting Mutfwang into the APC to “helping Pharaoh cross the Red Sea,” warning that the governor would “destroy the party from within.”

The association added that their own defection from the PDP was driven by a desire for “inclusiveness, fairness, and purposeful leadership,” claiming that Mutfwang abandoned many of those who worked for his 2023 electoral victory. Hon. Mutbel further maintained that the APC does not need the governor to strengthen its electoral chances, saying “all those who supported him have already fled.”

As the rumours continue to spread, analysts note that Plateau’s political terrain remains highly volatile, with shifting alliances shaping the build-up to the next election cycle.

The controversy unfolds amid heightened political tension and rising insecurity across Nigeria, with recent attacks and emerging threats deepening public anxiety over governance and national stability.