Connect with us

News

What the jury will actually decide in the case of Elon Musk vs. Sam Altman over OpenAI

info

Published

on

IMG 4131 rotated.jpg

Nine California jurors are now deliberating over the future of OpenAI, the world-leading artificial intelligence lab.

While the trial exploring Elon Musk’s case against OpenAI’s other cofounders and Microsoft has covered territory ranging from the breakup of the founders in 2018 to Altman’s firing and rehiring in 2023, the jurors will be considering a set of fairly narrow questions.

  • Breach of charitable trust — essentially, did OpenAI and cofounders Sam Altman and Greg Brockman violate a specific agreement with Musk to use his donations to OpenAI for a specific, charitable purpose and not general use by the non-profit?
  • Unjust enrichment — did the defendants use Musk’s donations to enrich themselves through OpenAI’s for-profit arm, instead of for charitable purposes?
  • Aiding and abetting breach of charitable trust — Did Microsoft, through its interactions with OpenAI, know that Musk had specific conditions on its donations, and play a significant role in causing harm to Musk?

OpenAI has also made three arguments in its defense that the jury will weigh:

  • Statute of limitations — a legal deadline by which a lawsuit must be filed. Here, if OpenAI can prove that any harms to Musk happened before August 5, 2021 for the first count; August 5, 2022 for the second count; and November 14, 2021 for the first count, then his claims will be moot.
  • Unreasonable delay — Musk, by filing his lawsuit in 2024, delayed his claim in a way that made his request for damages unreasonable.
  • Unclean hands — a legal doctrine holding that Musk’s conduct related to his claims against OpenAI was unconscionable and renders them invalid.

If Musk wins out, it could mean the end of OpenAI as a for-profit company, but it’s not entirely clear what will result. Next week, the judge will begin a set of new hearings where lawyers from both sides will debate what the consequences of a verdict in favor of the plaintiffs might be. That process could be rendered moot by a negative verdict, however.

Breach of charitable trust

Musk’s attorneys say the defendants clearly understood that Musk wanted to support a non-profit that would ensure the benefits of AI to the world, and prevent it from being controlled by any one organization. In particular, they say a $10 billion investment from Microsoft in 2023 into OpenAI’s for-profit affiliate—the first to happen after the statute of limitations—was the event that turned Musk’s concern into conviction.

That deal, Musk’s lawyers say, was different from previous investments and led to OpenAI’s investors being enriched by the company’s commercial products, at the expense of the charitable mission of AI safety that Musk promoted.

OpenAI’s attorneys have asked every witness to describe specific restrictions put on Musk’s donations, and none have, including his financial adviser Jared Birchall, his chief of staff Sam Teller, or his special adviser Shivon Zilis. They say everyone involved agreed that private fundraising would be required to achieve its goals, and note that Musk himself attempted to launch an OpenAI-affiliated for-profit he would personally control, and later to merge OpenAI into his company Tesla. They also note the organization’s other donors haven’t said their charitable trust was violated.

Importantly, a forensic accountant hired by OpenAI testified that all of Musk’s donations had been used by OpenAI well before the key date of August 5, 2021. That is evidence that Musk’s donations were already used for their purpose well before he brought his lawsuit, invalidating any charitable trust that may have existed.

Mainly, they insist that the for-profit affiliate that conducts most of OpenAI’s actual activity continues to fulfill the organization’s mission, and has generated nearly $200 billion in equity value to support the non-profit foundation. Notably, Sam Altman argued that providing ChatGPT for free helps fulfill the mission of sharing the benefits of AI with the world.

Unjust enrichment

The plaintiffs point to the multibillion-dollar valuations of stakes held by OpenAI founders like Brockman and Ilya Sutskever, as well as Microsoft itself, as a sign that Musk’s donations were ultimately used for personal benefit, as opposed to supporting the mission of the charity. They argue that the work at OpenAI’s for-profit was commercially focused, while the foundation itself was left essentially dormant, without full-time employees, and, ultimately, not even in control of the for-profit.

OpenAI says all of Musk’s contributions were used by the foundation by 2020, and that equity distributions came well after he left the organization in 2018. Even beforehand, evidence shows the key players agreed that being able to compensate researchers with stock was key to developing AGI, the hypothetical form of AI capable of performing any intellectual task a human can. OpenAI executives maintain that the for-profit’s work meaningfully advanced the foundation’s mission, including safety activities. They say the non-profit board continues to control the for-profit, and instituted new governance controls following “the blip,” when Altman was fired by OpenAI’s non-profit board in 2023 for lack of candor and then rehired just days later.

Aiding and abetting

Musk’s case focused on the events of the blip, when Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella, whose company depended on OpenAI’s tech, was personally involved with helping to bring Altman back and creating a new board to govern OpenAI. They note that Microsoft executives wondered if their commercial agreement might conflict with the non-profit’s goals, and suggest that Microsoft’s commercial priorities led OpenAI away from its mission. They’ve focused attention on a clause in Microsoft’s agreement with OpenAI that gave Microsoft veto rights over major corporate decisions at OpenAI.

Microsoft’s witnesses have insisted that the company’s executives didn’t know of any specific conditions on Musk’s donations despite extensive due diligence, and never vetoed any decision by OpenAI. They note that the company’s investments and compute power allowed OpenAI to achieve its biggest triumphs.

Statute of Limitations

Musk has suggested that his skepticism of his cofounders grew over time, until in the fall of 2022 he finally decided they had betrayed him when he found out about Microsoft’s plans for a new $10 billion investment that took place in 2023. He wouldn’t file his lawsuit until mid-2024.

OpenAI’s attorneys argue that the terms of that deal were spelled out in a term sheet for a previous fundraising round in 2018, which Musk received and his advisers reviewed, but Musk said he didn’t read in detail. They also note numerous blog posts and other communications from over the years that show Musk could have known what OpenAI was doing well before he brought them to court, including tweets where Musk criticized the company years before the suit. Zilis, Musk’s adviser, even voted to approve these transactions as a member of the OpenAI board.

Ultimately, the OpenAI attorneys emphasize that Musk’s formal role in the organization ended in 2018 and his last donations took place in 2020.

Unreasonable delay

OpenAI’s attorneys say the real reason that Musk filed his suit was he realized that he was wrong about OpenAI, after its launch of ChatGPT revolutionized the business of artificial intelligence. They argue that OpenAI has operated under its current structure since its first Microsoft investment in 2018, and that forcing the organization to restructure eight years later is unreasonable.

Unclean hands

There is evidence that Musk was planning his own competing AI efforts while he was still the chair of OpenAI, and hired OpenAI employees to work on AI at Tesla. OpenAI’s attorneys argue that these efforts undermined OpenAI at a time when it was using Musk’s donations to pursue its mission. They noted that Zilis, the mother of three of Musk’s children, didn’t disclose her personal relationship to other OpenAI board members for years. And they argue that Musk withheld his donations in 2017 in an effort to win control of a planned for-profit affiliate of OpenAI. Finally, “Mr. Musk abandoned OpenAI for dead in 2018,” Bill Savitt, OpenAI’s lead attorney, told the jury.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Business

COP31: Six billion tonnes of emissions from burning wood may be missing from climate reports – Report

info

Published

on

IMG 6156.jpeg

At least six billion tonnes of carbon dioxide from burning wood and other biomass for heat and power have been recorded as zero in countries’ energy accounts since 1990, according to a report released by the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) at the UN climate summit in Antalya, Turkey.

RSPB, a British conservation charity, said on Monday that the amount is about equal to the annual emissions of the United States.

Bioenergy is energy made from organic material such as trees, crops and food waste, according to the RSPB.

Matt Williams, the independent energy analyst who carried out the analysis, told the audience at a press conference that he examined the greenhouse gas reports countries have submitted to the UN climate body since 1990. Some countries did not report every year while others left parts of their reports blank, he said.

“And because of missing data, this is probably an underestimate,” Mr Williams said.

The gap comes from guidance issued by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which assigns the carbon from harvested wood to the forest sector of the country where the trees are cut, he said. The country that burns the wood records the emissions in its energy sector as zero and often has no information on whether the felled trees are replaced.

PT WHATSAPP CHANNEL
Dangote Refinery AD

That guidance dates from the 1990s, when most biomass was burnt in the country that grew it, Mr Williams said. Wood pellets are now traded internationally, and five major economies spent nearly $250 billion subsidising bioenergy between 2002 and 2024, he said, citing research by the Environmental Paper Network.

Ruairi Brogan, a senior policy officer at the RSPB, said the charity wants the panel to change its guidelines so that emissions are counted where biomass is burnt.

“It’s not just fossil fuels that have to go at this COP,” Mr Brogan said.

Credits from Nigeria’s wood stoves

The same accounting treats wood burnt in poorer countries differently, said Janaina Uemura of the Global Forest Coalition, which organised the press conference with the RSPB. Ms Uemura said household fuelwood in those countries is counted as emissions that can be turned into carbon credits, while wood burnt in power stations in richer countries is counted as zero.

A carbon credit represents one tonne of emissions avoided, which a buyer can count against its own. Nigeria authorised the stove maker BURN to sell 5.2 million such credits internationally in March. A second approval, for close to four million credits, went to UpEnergy, a Uganda-based developer.

Sixty-two per cent of Nigerian households cook with wood, according to the National Clean Cooking Policy. Wood fuel is the leading cause of forest degradation in the country, which burns about 34.7 million tonnes more wood a year than its forests can sustainably supply, according to a World Bank study published last year.

Carbon capture push at the summit

The organisers also criticised technologies that capture or remove carbon dioxide. Kwami Kpondzo of the Global Forest Coalition and HOME Alliance, who is from Togo, said removal methods that depend on biomass would take land from communities in developing countries.

“The only way to cut the emissions is to do it at the source,” Mr Kpondzo said.

A record 700 carbon capture lobbyists registered for COP31, more than the 699 delegates in the 50 smallest national delegations combined, the Centre for International Environmental Law said on Monday.

READ ALSO: COP31: African activists fault just transition talks, demand inclusion, accountability

Nigeria’s long-term low-emission strategy emphasises gas power plants fitted with carbon capture and storage, according to Climate Action Tracker.

Both carbon removal and bioenergy are at issue in the first draft of the summit’s main decision, which was released on Monday. Two of its paragraphs make room for carbon removal technologies, the campaign group 350.org said, while a third promotes Turkey’s target of 35 per cent electrification by 2035 “regardless of the electricity mix”.

The RSPB wants bioenergy excluded from that target before ministers adopt the decision on Friday, 20 November.

“Big bioenergy is a dangerous distraction. Now leaders must listen,” Mr Brogan said.


Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue Reading

News

Galaxy Backbone GOVMAIL adoption crosses 150,000 users – Technology Times

info

Published

on

Galaxy Backbone Limited (GBB), the Federal Government-owned information and communications technology (ICT) infrastructure provider, says more than 150,000 public and civil servants have been onboarded onto its Government Official Mail (GOVMAIL) platform.

The milestone, underscoring growing adoption of government-managed digital communication infrastructure across Nigeria’s public sector, comes as the Federal Government intensifies efforts to digitise public service operations, strengthen information security and accelerate the transition from paper-based administrative processes to electronic communication and records management.

GOVMAIL provides official email services to Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDAs), with its infrastructure hosted on government-owned data centres and supported by enterprise-grade cybersecurity systems, according to GBB.

Galaxy Backbone said the platform is designed to provide public institutions with secure and reliable communication services while strengthening local digital capabilities and government control over official information.

The company described GOVMAIL as more than an email service, positioning it as part of Nigeria’s broader digital government infrastructure and efforts to strengthen data sovereignty.

“But GOVMAIL is more than an email platform. It represents the value of building local digital capabilities, strengthening data sovereignty and ensuring that government institutions have access to technology and support that understand their needs,” Galaxy Backbone said.

The platform, GBB says, incorporates email encryption, spam filtering, malware protection, data backup and recovery services. It also provides calendar management, meeting scheduling and task management capabilities, with access through desktop computers, web browsers and mobile devices.

Its services operate under official government email domains, including fedcs.gov.ng and MDA-specific domains, while data is hosted on government infrastructure.

According to Galaxy Backbone, the locally managed infrastructure gives government institutions greater control over their information while providing access to technical support within Nigeria.

GOVMAIL adoption rises following directive on official correspondence

The reported increase in GOVMAIL adoption follows the Federal Government’s push to standardise official electronic communication across the public service.

In June 2026, Didi Esther Walson-Jack, Head of the Civil Service of the Federation, announced that more than 115,000 active GOVMAIL accounts were already in use across the public service.

She also declared an end to the use of personal email accounts for official government transactions, directing civil servants to adopt institutional email platforms for official correspondence.

The latest figure of more than 150,000 onboarded users represents an increase of at least 35,000 over the active-account figure disclosed in June, although the two figures describe different adoption measures: users onboarded and active accounts in use.

Walson-Jack also disclosed in June that the Federal Government had fully digitised the work processes of 38 ministries and extra-ministerial departments under its paperless civil service initiative.

The initiative is intended to reduce dependence on physical documentation, improve administrative efficiency and strengthen the use of digital systems for government operations.

Data sovereignty becomes central to government digital infrastructure

The expansion of GOVMAIL also highlights the Federal Government’s emphasis on locally managed digital infrastructure for public sector operations.

By hosting official email services on government-owned infrastructure, Galaxy Backbone sees the platform as a means of strengthening institutional control over government communications and information assets.

Its security features, including encryption, malware protection, spam filtering and data recovery, are designed to support the confidentiality, availability and integrity of official correspondence.

The platform’s adoption also reflects the growing importance of digital infrastructure in government administration, as public institutions increasingly depend on electronic communication, digital records and interconnected systems to deliver services.

Continue Reading

Trending