Connect with us

News

Complex Legal Battle Unfolds in Plateau State Amid Election Petition Cases

editor

Published

on

Plateau LGAs map

Plateau State has found itself embroiled in a complex legal battle due to the sheer volume of Election Petition cases in Nigeria this year. In an effort to ensure compliance with Section 285(6) of the 1999 constitution, which mandates the completion of such cases within 180 days (6 months), the Chief Justice of Nigeria has established a single Tribunal with separate Panels dedicated to expeditiously resolving these matters.

Plateau State, much like several other states grappling with an abundance of cases, is hosting three (3) Panels, each assigned specific responsibilities:

1. Governorship Panel Cases

2. Legislative Houses Cases

The Legislative Houses Panel further subdivides into:

  • Panel A
  • Panel B

The Legislative Houses Panel A and B recently delivered their verdicts on the cases before them, but unfortunately, their judgments conflicted. One Panel deemed the Plateau State cases as Pre-election matters, while the other Panel asserted they were Post-election matters.

The Panel ruling in favor of Post-election matters contended that the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) lacked the necessary structure to sponsor candidates for elections, including the organization of a Primary Election. Consequently, they deemed all votes for PDP legislators, which led to their victory according to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), as wasted votes. As a result, candidates from parties with the second-highest number of votes, namely the All Progressives Congress (APC) and Labour Party (LP), emerged as beneficiaries, akin to a situation witnessed in Zamfara in 2019.

On Friday, September 22nd, 2023, the Governorship Election Panel finally delivered its judgment, classifying the Governorship election as a Pre-election matter. Essentially, this means that, regarding the Plateau State Governorship election case, the internal workings and structures of the APC or LP are irrelevant; the focus shifts away from how the Plateau State Governor became a candidate in the general election.

This unique situation has made Plateau State a focal point of legal intrigue. With two conflicting judgments emerging from the same Tribunal, courtesy of different Panels but based on identical facts, a clear resolution is now imperative. Consequently, APC, PDP, and LP must all pursue appeals. The Court of Appeal will ultimately issue the FINAL judgment on the candidates for Legislative Houses (Senate, House of Representatives, and House of Assembly), marking the end of those cases.

However, Plateau State’s peculiarity extends further. Unlike other states, where Governorship election cases conclude at the Court of Appeal, they continue to the Supreme Court. Thus, in a historic twist within Nigeria’s legal landscape, the Court of Appeal may deliver a FINAL judgment in the cases of Senators and members of the House of Representatives and Assembly, while the Supreme Court may potentially reverse the decision in the Governorship case, even though the former group will not be subject to the Supreme Court’s jurisdiction.

The unfolding drama in Plateau State promises to be a legal spectacle, and the outcome remains shrouded in uncertainty. Indeed, Plateau State’s legal conundrum is truly SPECIAL.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

I can’t be suspended by ward – Jigawa ADC chieftain Gantsa

info

Published

on

Gantsa

‎

‎A member of the African Democratic Congress, ADC, National Executive Committee, Aliyu Gantsa, has rejected his 12-month suspension by the party's leadership in Buji Local Government Area of Jigawa State, describing the decision as unconstitutional and invalid.

‎

‎Speaking in reaction to the development, Gantsa insisted that the ward executives lacked the constitutional authority to suspend him from the party.

‎Gantsa accused the Jigawa State leadership of the party of orchestrating the suspension in an attempt to weaken his political influence within the ADC.

‎

‎"I am a member of the National Executive Committee of the ADC. Ward executives have no constitutional grounds or authority to suspend me. Their decision violates the party's constitution and is therefore invalid," he said.

‎

‎He maintained that he remained a legitimate and active member of the ADC despite the suspension announced by the party's executives at ward level.

‎

‎Gantsa also vowed to challenge the decision through the appropriate channels provided by the party's constitution.

‎

‎DAILY POST reports that the ADC leadership in Buji Local Government Area had announced Gantsa's suspension for 12 months over alleged anti-party activities.

‎According to the statement, the suspension took effect on October 19, 2026, and would last until October 19, 2027.

‎

‎The party accused Gantsa of violating its rules, creating divisions among members and openly supporting a candidate who lost the party's primary election.

I can’t be suspended by ward – Jigawa ADC chieftain Gantsa

Continue Reading

News

Amnesty condemns four-year jail sentence for Kaduna journalist Farida Isiak

info

Published

on

Amnesty International has condemned the arrest, detention and four-year prison sentence handed to 23-year-old journalist Farida Isiak in Kaduna State, describing the case as vindictive and an attempt to silence press freedom.

The organisation said the journalist’s arrest and subsequent sentencing were linked to her attempt to expose alleged police misconduct involving her parents.

Isiak, a reporter with Nagarta Radio in Kaduna, was reportedly arrested at about 10pm on Monday, October 20, by police officers under the command of the Divisional Police Officer of Mararaban Jos, Usman Adamu.

According to Amnesty International, the incident began with a disagreement between Isiak’s mother and a neighbour over a ₦100 change during a charcoal sale.

The organisation alleged that police officers initially arrested her mother and later detained her father when he went to seek her release, using their detention to compel the journalist to report to the police station.

When Isiak arrived, officers allegedly accused her of defamation over a Facebook post criticising their treatment of her parents.

Amnesty International said she deleted the post and apologised in an attempt to secure her parents’ release, but the police allegedly continued to detain her before taking her to a Sharia Court in Kawo.

The court subsequently sentenced her to four years in prison or a fine of ₦1.75 million on a defamation charge.

Describing the proceedings as a sham trial, Amnesty International said the court failed to address the alleged police misconduct that triggered the incident.

“The arrest, detention, and hasty sentencing of Farida Isiak are a flagrant abuse of power by the police and weaponisation of the judicial system to silence free speech and intimidate journalists,” the organisation said.

It added that detaining the journalist’s parents to compel her to surrender to the police was an unlawful tactic that violated the rule of law.

“Demanding accountability for police actions is a constitutional right,” Amnesty International said.

The human rights organisation called on the Kaduna State Police Command and Nigerian judicial authorities to secure Isiak’s immediate release, drop the charges against her and cancel the fine imposed by the court.

It also urged the Nigeria Police Force to launch a full and independent investigation into the conduct of the officers involved in the alleged unlawful detention of the journalist’s family.

Amnesty International further called on Nigerian authorities to stop using defamation charges and the judicial system to harass journalists and restrict press freedom.

The organisation warned that the case raises concerns about the protection of freedom of expression and the ability of journalists to hold public institutions accountable without fear of intimidation or retaliation.

Amnesty condemns four-year jail sentence for Kaduna journalist Farida Isiak

Continue Reading

Trending