Connect with us

Health

Jos hospital denies negligence in nursing student’s death

info

Published

on

494286516 122213094356183598 3511338553962063193 n.jpg

The National Orthopaedic Hospital, Jos, has denied allegations of medical negligence following the death of a nursing student, Raphael Bilat.

In a statement on Wednesday, the hospital’s management said its medical team immediately activated emergency response procedures and administered life-saving interventions.

Some of the deceased’s colleagues had claimed that he did not receive adequate medical attention.

The hospital said Mr Bilat was brought to its Accident and Emergency Unit at about 6:05 p.m. on Monday, 16 November, after collapsing during a football match.

Mr Bilat’s death sparked outrage among colleagues and members of the nursing community, with allegations of inadequate emergency facilities and delays in medical intervention at the orthopaedic hospital and the Jos University Teaching Hospital (JUTH), where he was subsequently transferred.

One of his colleagues, Ifeoma Onyibe, alleged that essential emergency supplies, including oxygen, were unavailable when the student was brought to the hospital.

PT WHATSAPP CHANNEL
Dangote Refinery AD

She also claimed that the students waited for about two hours without access to the doctor on duty.

The hospital, however, gave a different account, saying the student was already in an extremely critical condition when he arrived.

According to the statement, Mr Bilat was accompanied by a large group of student nurses following his sudden collapse on a football pitch.

The hospital said he was clinically unresponsive, pale and cold to the touch, with fixed and dilated pupils and a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 3/15, indicating profound unresponsiveness.

It said nurses on duty immediately commenced resuscitation while the doctor on call was notified.

The medical team established an intravenous line and conducted a random blood sugar test, which returned a reading of 8.4 millimoles per litre.

The attending doctor reportedly confirmed that the patient was unresponsive following cardiac arrest, prompting continued cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), administration of intravenous fluids and 200 milligrams of hydrocortisone.

The hospital said cardiac monitoring showed a body temperature of 31 degrees Celsius, while his pulse, blood pressure and oxygen saturation could not be recorded.

It added that intravenous adrenaline was administered and supplemental oxygen provided, but the patient remained unresponsive.

Hospital alleges interference with resuscitation

The hospital further alleged that efforts to resuscitate the student were disrupted by a large crowd of student nurses who overwhelmed its Accident and Emergency Unit.

It said the crowd obstructed medical specialists from taking full control of the patient’s management despite repeated appeals by hospital personnel.

According to the management, some students insisted on performing endotracheal intubation themselves and administering what it described as unapproved doses of emergency medications, including up to six ampoules of intravenous adrenaline and atropine, against the attending physician’s advice.

The hospital said the situation overwhelmed its internal security personnel and operatives of the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps deployed to the facility.

Despite the alleged disruption, the management said its medical team continued resuscitation efforts.

It added that the students subsequently requested an ambulance to transfer Mr Bilat to JUTH for further treatment.

At the time of the request, the hospital said his body temperature had dropped to 30 degrees Celsius, his oxygen saturation was 42 per cent, while his pulse and blood pressure remained unrecordable.

A second doctor on call reportedly managed to reach the patient through the crowd, reassessed his condition and explained the critical prognosis to the students before authorising the transfer.

The hospital’s ambulance was deployed at 8:59 p.m. and departed at 9:05 p.m., accompanied by a nurse, a porter and student representatives.

The statement said resuscitation continued throughout the journey, with the patient remaining unresponsive and his oxygen saturation at 42 per cent.

He was handed over to the Accident and Emergency team at JUTH at 9:20 p.m., while the ambulance returned to the orthopaedic hospital at 10:05 p.m.

Hospital defends emergency response

The management maintained that it provided emergency care in accordance with national healthcare directives, insisting that life-saving medications, intravenous fluids and emergency drugs were deployed as required.

It also disclosed that another student from the same group was brought to its Accident and Emergency Unit during the incident in critical condition.

According to the hospital, its medical team attended to the second student and successfully stabilised her before she regained consciousness.

While expressing condolences to the family of the deceased, his colleagues and the wider nursing community, the hospital appealed for calm and urged the public to respect medical protocols during emergencies.

It said attempts by people without clinical authority to take over emergency procedures and administer restricted medications could compromise patient care.

READ ALSO: Reps propose fines, licence withdrawal for hospitals that delay emergency treatment

However, the hospital’s statement did not independently establish the cause of Mr Bilat’s collapse or address all the specific allegations concerning the availability and functionality of emergency equipment, including reported concerns about a defibrillator.

The conflicting accounts have raised questions about emergency preparedness, the availability of critical equipment and coordination between medical personnel and accompanying students during life-threatening situations.

There are also questions surrounding the circumstances of the student’s transfer between the two federal hospitals.

The orthopaedic hospital said Mr Bilat was handed over to JUTH at 9:20 p.m. on Monday, while earlier accounts placed the time he was pronounced dead at about 9 p.m.


Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Health

JUTH Student Nurse Anaesthetist Dies After Collapsing During Football Match in Jos

info

Published

on

FB IMG 1795067039210.jpg

A student nurse anaesthetist at the Jos University Teaching Hospital (JUTH), Plateau State, Damak Raphael Bilat, has died after collapsing during a farewell football match, three days after completing his professional examinations.

Bilat, a trainee at the School of Post-Basic Nursing Anaesthesia, reportedly collapsed about 10 minutes into the football match on Monday, November 16, 2026, shortly after scoring a goal.

The match was organised by fellow students to celebrate the completion of their professional examinations with the Nursing and Midwifery Council of Nigeria (NMCN).

According to reports, Bilat was rushed to the Federal Orthopaedic Hospital, Jos, for emergency medical attention before he was subsequently transferred to JUTH, where he was pronounced dead at about 9 pm.

His death has sparked concerns and allegations of inadequate emergency medical response at the two hospitals, with some of his colleagues accusing the facilities of failing to provide timely and appropriate care.

Colleague Alleges Delayed Emergency Response

One of Bilat’s colleagues, Ifeoma Onyibe, who reportedly shared details of the incident, alleged that the National Orthopaedic Hospital in Jos lacked some essential emergency equipment and supplies when the student was brought in.

She claimed that oxygen and adrenaline were initially unavailable, while the students reportedly had to assist with resuscitation efforts using equipment obtained from the hospital’s theatre.

Onyibe further alleged that they spent about two hours at the hospital without seeing the doctor on call and that the ambulance driver had to be summoned from home before Bilat could be transferred to JUTH.

She also claimed that upon arrival at JUTH, they were informed that the hospital’s defibrillator was not functional.

The allegations have raised questions about emergency preparedness, availability of life-saving equipment and the response of medical personnel at the two federal health institutions.

Calls for Investigation

Bilat’s death has triggered calls from colleagues and members of the nursing community for an investigation into the circumstances surrounding his death and the alleged lapses in emergency care.

The advocacy group Fellow Nurses Africa has called on the Nursing and Midwifery Council of Nigeria, the Federal Ministry of Health and Social Welfare and relevant hospital authorities to investigate the incident and strengthen emergency response systems in healthcare and nursing training institutions.

The group also raised concerns about the need for functional resuscitation equipment, emergency medications, trained personnel and effective referral systems.

However, the cause of Bilat’s collapse has not been officially established, and the allegations of medical negligence have not been independently verified.

As of the time of filing this report, neither the Federal Orthopaedic Hospital, Jos, nor JUTH had issued an official statement regarding the incident.

Bilat’s death has left his classmates, colleagues and members of the nursing community mourning the loss of a young healthcare professional whose life ended shortly after completing his professional examinations.

Continue Reading

Health

WHO calls for urgent action to curb drug resistance in Africa

info

Published

on

HRiUNIUa4AAiLxt.jpg

The World Health Organisation (WHO) has called on African countries to strengthen efforts to tackle antimicrobial resistance (AMR), warning that drug-resistant infections continue to threaten lives and undermine healthcare across the continent.

WHO said bacterial AMR was associated with an estimated 4.7 million deaths globally in 2021, with sub-Saharan Africa recording the highest rates of AMR-associated mortality.

The WHO Regional Director for Africa, Mohamed Janabi, made the call in a message ahead of World AMR Awareness Week, observed from 18 to 24 November, under the theme, “One Health, One Action: Prevent AMR Now”.

AMR occurs when bacteria, viruses, fungi and parasites no longer respond to medicines used to treat infections, making diseases more difficult to manage.

Mr Janabi said inappropriate use of antimicrobials in humans and animals, poor infection prevention, inadequate water and sanitation, and unsafe waste disposal were contributing to the spread of drug resistance.

He called for stronger action across human, animal, plant and environmental health, stressing that preventing infections would reduce the need for antimicrobial medicines.

PT WHATSAPP CHANNEL
Dangote Refinery AD

Progress and gaps in Africa

According to WHO, all 47 countries in the African Region now have national action plans on AMR, although implementation varies.

All 47 countries are also enrolled in WHO’s Global Antimicrobial Resistance and Use Surveillance System, while 44 can conduct susceptibility testing for priority bacterial pathogens to help determine which antibiotics are likely to work.

The agency said 36 countries had adopted its Access, Watch and Reserve (AWaRe) classification of antibiotics to promote appropriate prescribing and responsible use.

WHO is also targeting a 70 per cent share of antibiotics used in human healthcare coming from the Access group by 2030.

Coordination across sectors has also improved, with the number of countries having functional One Health AMR governance mechanisms increasing from 15 in 2023 to 29 in 2026.

However, Mr Janabi said countries must translate these gains into stronger protection for communities through increased investment in laboratories, surveillance, infection prevention and responsible antimicrobial use.

He urged governments to fund national action plans, establish clear responsibilities, and measure progress.

Nigeria to host global AMR conference

Nigeria is expected to host the fifth Global High-Level Ministerial Conference on Antimicrobial Resistance in Abuja from 6 to 8 December.

READ ALSO: WHO urges concrete action on antimicrobial resistance worldwide

The conference, the first of its kind to be held on African soil, is expected to bring together government officials, public health experts, and other stakeholders to review progress and strengthen global action against AMR.

It will be held under the theme, “One Health: Advancing Global AMR Commitments through Local Action”.

The meeting is expected to focus on translating global commitments into practical interventions across human, animal and environmental health, as well as strengthening financing and accountability.

Mr Janabi called on health professionals, farmers, researchers, development partners and communities to contribute to efforts to prevent drug resistance.

He urged members of the public to keep vaccinations up to date, practice good hand hygiene, use antibiotics only when prescribed by qualified health professionals and avoid sharing leftover medicines.

“AMR is everyone’s business. Let us each choose one concrete action this week, sustain it throughout the year, and encourage others to act,” he said.


Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue Reading

Trending